This First Person column reflects the experiences of Hilary Duff, who was raised in northern Ontario. For further details on CBC’s First Person stories, please check the FAQ.
Recently, I received an email that offered a complimentary Brazilian lymphatic drainage massage in Hamilton, Ontario. The catch? The message was not meant for me but for the other Hilary Duff, intended to help her unwind before her sold-out concert in Toronto this Saturday.
Hold on. What? You might easily overlook the byline of this article. However, if you scroll back up, you’ll notice my name is indeed Hilary Duff. We share the same name.
This brings me back to the massage situation. In case you haven’t heard, Hilary Duff is currently on a comeback tour, performing in cities like London, New York, Los Angeles, and one show in Canada.
Tens of thousands of Hilary Duff fans were left disappointed after the Toronto leg of her upcoming tour was quickly sold out. Of just 2,500 available tickets, many went to scalpers who are now reselling at spiked prices. CBC’s Madi Wong explains why a lack of regulations around ticket resale may be to blame.
The buzz surrounding Duff’s return to the stage after nearly 18 years has led to a flood of emails in my inbox. It appears that many people find it easy to overlook the differences in our appearances on my writing and photography websites and simply click “email.”
I’m certainly not the only one experiencing this phenomenon of sharing a name with a celebrity. Many individuals have name twins among famous personalities. During my university years, I had a friend named Emily Dickinson. A colleague’s father was named George Harrison. It’s a common occurrence.
While it’s not unusual, what makes my situation unique, I would argue, is the longevity and widespread influence of Hilary Duff’s cultural impact.
I believe it’s fair to say that she was a pivotal figure for the millennial generation, representing a staple for North American teenagers during a time when social media and YouTube were non-existent. We all consumed the same television shows and films, and everyone recognized our names.
It was in 1998, in Rouyn-Noranda, Quebec, that I first spotted our name on the big screen (or rather, my childhood friend’s basement television). It was a movie night during a sleepover, and one of Duff’s early films, Casper Meets Wendy, was playing on the VHS. At the age of eight, I vividly recall my surprise and thrill.
Following that was her rise to fame with The Lizzie McGuire Show, which aired for 65 episodes from 2001 to 2004. This was soon followed by her music career and then The Lizzie McGuire Movie.

Hilary Duff starred in the show, The Lizzie McGuire Show, which ran for two seasons. (Disney Channel)
By the time I reached middle school, my parents were purchasing glossy Hilary Duff magazines so I could cut our name out and use it for collages on my bedroom walls; in high school, I dressed up as the “other” Hilary Duff for Halloween, spending my part-time job earnings on her Stuff by Hilary Duff clothing line from Zellers (RIP).
When Facebook launched a few months later, I received friend requests and “pokes” from people wanting to connect with a celebrity. At one point, my account was even suspended until I provided Facebook with a copy of my driver’s license to verify my identity.

The celebrity shrine that was displayed in 14-year-old Hilary Duff’s bedroom. There are two photos of the celebrity Hilary Duff, to the left and right of Bow Wow. (Submitted by Hilary Duff)
Given our slight age difference — at 35, I’m just three years younger than my famous namesake — the jokes surrounding my name have been a constant in my life. It’s a given that when people learn my full name, they believe they are about to deliver a clever quip I’ve never encountered before.
For the most part, I find the coincidence amusing and occasionally even advantageous — for some reason, people never seem to forget my name. But I must admit: it can become tiresome after a while.
It has also been intriguing to observe the emails and Facebook messages I have received over the years. These provide a unique glimpse into the world of celebrity:
● School assignments: “You honestly made my childhood with Lizzy McGuire. Right now for English we are allowed to choose our own topic for our research paper and I want to write about: the ethical dilemma of using childhood actors/influencers and their psychological standing as they grow up.”
● Wedding invitations: “We are your biggest fans! We’re so grateful for all you’ve unknowingly added to our self-expression, our joy and our love in the past five years of our relationship and feel a bit cheeky but excited to extend an invite to you!”
● Requests related to the comeback tour: “I’m just giving this a shot. I was trying to get tickets to your show in Toronto as my fiancé and her best friend have loved you since you were a kid and I was trying to make a Christmas miracle happen. The tickets apparently sold out in minutes.”
I’ve received podcast invitations from India, support requests from asylum seekers in Somalia, and offers to try breastfeeding products from American brands since Duff became a mother.
At times, the messages are heart-wrenching: a mother of a sick child trying to obtain a signed photo from Hilary Duff. In these moments, I’ve thought about printing a picture of my blonde counterpart and scribbling our signatures. Although the temptation exists, I have never responded to such emails. This is partly due to my reluctance to engage with internet creeps (see below) and partly because I lack the time or patience to explain that “yes, this is Hilary Duff. No, not that one.”

A sample of the emails Duff has received that were intended for the other Hilary Duff. Some content has been blurred to maintain the privacy of the senders. (Hilary Duff)
Naturally, I have also received romantic-themed emails, ranging from the innocuous subject line “Dating and admiration” to the more alarming and often explicitly forward messages from fans. These are promptly marked as spam. The others are sorted into the “Hilary Duff fanmail” folder on my Gmail account.
Our lives intersected again when Duff was romantically involved with then NHL player Mike Comrie. This didn’t significantly affect me — only that in 2009, Comrie played for the Ottawa Senators — during my second year at Carleton University in Ottawa.
Seeing images of Hilary Duff supporting Comrie from the stands at what is now the Canadian Tire Centre was both amusing and unsettling. “Of all the places she could be, she’s in Ottawa,” I thought to myself.

Actor and singer Hilary Duff, right, cheers as her partner Mike Comrie’s team, the Ottawa Senators, played the Toronto Maple Leafs in Ottawa on March 9, 2009. Ottawa won 2-1. (Fred Chartrand/The Canadian Press)
To my knowledge, Hilary Duff’s performance in Toronto this Saturday will be the closest our paths have crossed in years. I attempted to acquire tickets for the concert, but it seems that sharing a name doesn’t grant any special privileges.
If I had managed to get in, what would I have done? Created a giant poster proclaiming: “We’re name twins!”? Honestly, I just want her to be aware that there’s another person with her name. I want to share the friend requests, messages, and freebies I’ve been receiving for years, to relieve myself of the obligation to respond, and to achieve a full-circle moment as a millennial.
However, since that seems unlikely, her return to music symbolizes the next chapter in our ongoing coexistence, a humorous constant in my life for nearly thirty years.
As for the fan mail? It seems it truly is anything but outdated.
Do you have a compelling personal story that can bring understanding or help others? We want to hear from you. Here’s more info on how to pitch to us.

